Amazon, BBB Sue Website Allegedly Peddling Fake Reviews
They claim ReviewServiceUSA.com was selling both positive and negative reviews of products and businesses.
In a lawsuit filed July 18 in the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Washington, the companies accused the site of using phony customer accounts to share fake positive and negative reviews on Amazon product pages and BBB profiles.
These reviews, said the lawsuit, were sold to people who wanted to boost the ranking and rating of their products and businesses, which can give their pages more visibility.
According to court documents, ReviewServiceUSA.com also allegedly offered to post fake negative reviews to Amazon or a BBB page for those looking to impact a competitor.
In a screenshot shared in court documents, the website advertised a “Buy Amazon Reviews” service, charging $50 for per review.
The screenshot said reviews would be posted from different IP addresses and different devices, and that if Amazon removed the review, ReviewServiceUSA.com would replace it with another review.
ReviewServiceUSA.com offered a similar service for those looking to buy reviews on the BBB website, charging $60 for three reviews and $200 for 10 reviews, according to the lawsuit.
In addition to fake reviews, the website allegedly sold another service, “Buy Amazon Seller Accounts,” for between $280 and $500.
These accounts were said to come with all the necessary documents to set up an account, including phone numbers, the last four digits of Social Security numbers, driver’s licenses, and passports. The company also allegedly promised a replacement account if Amazon shut it down.
ReviewServiceUSA.com appears to be offline as of press time.
In a press release about the lawsuit, Amazon highlighted the importance of reviews to the overall shopping experience, giving consumers the ability to make informed purchase decisions.
“These fake reviews undermine trust in the reviews experience, which harms customers and sellers alike,” said the company.
Amazon has invested in methods of proactively stopping fake reviews, it said, including using machine-learning models and expert investigators, and taking legal action against fake review brokers.
It said it has stopped 250 million suspected fake reviews from its store in 2023.
“Despite the efforts of both Amazon and the BBB, fake reviews persist because schemes allowing bad actors to pay for five-star reviews are organized and orchestrated largely on third-party websites such as Review Service USA, or in dedicated groups on social media sites, as opposed to within Amazon’s stores or on the BBB website where the fake reviews are ultimately posted,” said the lawsuit.
Amazon filed a similar lawsuit in 2015 against operators of sites allegedly selling fake product reviews.
“Amazon is committed to ensuring reviews remain a trustworthy, insightful resource for consumers worldwide and we have zero tolerance for any attempts to mislead our customers through fake reviews,” said Claire O’Donnell, Amazon’s director of selling partner trust and store integrity.
“We’re grateful for the collaboration with the Better Business Bureau to hold these fake review brokers accountable for their deceitful actions. This lawsuit sends a clear message to bad actors that Amazon will use all available means to preserve the authenticity of product reviews.”
By teaming up, the two can combine their resources and expertise to fight back against deceptive practices, said Melanie McGovern, director of public relations and social media for International Association of Better Business Bureaus.
“The joint lawsuit will convey that fake reviews will not be tolerated. BBB remains committed to fostering trust and promoting integrity in the marketplace to protect consumers and honest businesses,” said McGovern.
Amazon and the BBB both prohibit fake reviews on their sites.
The companies said the goal of the lawsuit is to shut down ReviewServiceUSA’s operations.
The Latest
Said to be the first to write a jewelry sales manual for the industry, Zell is remembered for his zest for life.
The company outfitted the Polaris Dawn spaceflight crew with watches that will later be auctioned off to benefit St. Jude’s.
A buyer paid more than $100,000 for the gemstone known as “Little Willie,” setting a new auction record for a Scottish freshwater pearl.
Supplier Spotlight Sponsored by GIA.
Anita Gumuchian created the 18-karat yellow gold necklace using 189 carats of colored gemstones she spent the last 40 years collecting.
The giant gem came from Karowe, the same mine that yielded the 1,109-carat Lesedi La Rona and the 1,758-carat Sewelô diamond.
The three-stone ring was designed by Shahla Karimi Jewelry and represents Cuoco, her fiancé Tom Pelphrey, and their child.
Supplier Spotlight Sponsored by GIA
The Manhattan jewelry store has partnered with Xarissa B. of Jewel Boxing on a necklace capsule collection.
The jewelry historian discusses the history and cultural significance of jewelry throughout time and across the globe.
From fringe and tassels to pieces that give the illusion they are in motion, jewelry with movement is trending.
The designer and maker found community around her Philadelphia studio and creative inspiration on the sidewalks below it.
The change to accepted payment methods for Google Ads might seem like an irritation but actually is an opportunity, Emmanuel Raheb writes.
The industry consultant’s new book focuses on what she learned as an athlete recovering from a broken back.
The fair will take place on the West Coast for the first time, hosted by Altana Fine Jewelry in Oakland, California.
Hillelson is a second-generation diamantaire and CEO of Owl Financial Group.
Submissions in the categories of Jewelry Design, Media Excellence, and Retail Excellence will be accepted through this Friday, Aug. 23.
Known as “Little Willie,” it’s the largest freshwater pearl found in recent history in Scotland and is notable for its shape and color.
Clements Jewelers in Madisonville cited competition from larger retailers and online sellers as the driving factor.
The gemstone company is moving to the Ross Metal Exchange in New York City’s Diamond District.
Most of the 18th century royal jewelry taken from the Green Vault Museum in Dresden, Germany, in 2019 went back on display this week.
The Pittsburgh jeweler has opened a store in the nearby Nemacolin resort.
With a 40-carat cabochon emerald, this necklace is as powerful and elegant as a cat.
The Erlanger, Kentucky-based company was recognized for its reliability when it comes to repairs and fast turnaround times.
Unable to pay its debts, the ruby and sapphire miner is looking to restructure and become a “competitive and attractive” company.
The trend forecaster’s latest guide has intel on upcoming trends in the jewelry market.
Ingraham said she’ll use the scholarship funds to attend the Women’s Leadership Program at the Yale School of Management.